Strategic warning or strategic surprise?

by Justin Jones - 27 June 2012 10:41AM

Defence white papers normally include a paragraph or two on strategic warning. It is a fundamental aspect of defence policy and relates to strategic risk and hedging. The 2009 White Paper included the following commentary:

Australia has an enduring strategic interest in ensuring that any attempts by nearby states to develop the capacity for sustained military operations against us would be detected with as much warning time as possible. This would preferably be at least a decade, given the amount of lead time involved in building defence capabilities. 

We can be confident of getting this amount of strategic warning time...

Hold that thought.

In 1978 a naval officer writing in the ADF Journal analysed warning time for conflicts from 1939 onwards (left, a graph from this paper). He found that the average time from the first indication of impending war to the firing of first shots was 14.3 months. Analysing conflicts from 1950 onwards, the warning time reduced to 10.6 months and there was a 50% probability that conflict could occur in less than four months. 

To be fair, I have used some select sentences from the 2009 White Paper, neglecting the wider context. And our 1978 author was analysing conflicts during the Cold War. Still, if nothing else, it is an example of the importance of knowing exactly what the Government expects the ADF to be able to do, and of possessing the 'core force' (pre-'mobilisation') to do it. 

Lowy Institute for International Policy
Australia in the Asian Century

An Interpreter feature which ran from March to September of 2012, published to debate the Gillard Government's 'Australia in the Asian Century' White Paper, then in its research and consultation phase. Click here to see every post published in this series.

For commentary on the published White Paper, click here.

Australia's Defence Challenges

An Interpreter feature exploring Australia's defence challenges as the 2013 Defence White Paper planning process begins. Click here to see every post published in this series.

Selected Interpreter posts also appear in:

 
Business Spectator Caing online The Diplomat
 

Keep up-to-date with The Interpreter through:

iPhone App   iPhone App

RSS Feed   The Interpreter RSS Feed

Email Digest  

To receive a digest of posts from The Interpreter via email, enter your email address:

Receive a daily digest ->
Receive a weekly digest ->

Preview   |   Powered by FeedBlitz

Interpreting the Aid Review

This is the archive of a Lowy Institute blog which ran from January to April of 2011. It was published to debate the Gillard Government's independent aid review, which was then in its research and consultation phase. We offer this archive as a service to researchers and the general public.